U.S. Judge Allows New York Vape Lawsuit to Proceed
A U.S. federal judge has ruled that manufacturers and distributors of flavored vape brands such as Puff Bar cannot escape a lawsuit filed by New York State, which seeks to hold them accountable for their role in the youth vaping epidemic. The court determined that New York State has sufficiently alleged that these companies made misleading representations regarding the safety of their vape products.
Key Takeaways from the Ruling
- A U.S. federal judge has ruled that flavored vape companies, including Puff Bar, cannot dismiss a lawsuit filed by New York State.
- The court found that New York State sufficiently alleged that these companies made misleading claims that flavored vapes are “generally safe” and “harmless to users’ health.”
- The core allegations of the case remain intact, including claims of repeated violations of state and federal laws, creation of a public nuisance, and grossly negligent marketing practices.
- New York Attorney General Letitia James filed the nearly 200-page complaint in February 2025.
- The complaint alleges that the companies manufactured and distributed flavored disposable vapes that are illegal to sell at the retail level in New York.
Federal Judge Rejects Dismissal Request
April 7, 2026 — According to Law360, U.S. District Judge Margaret M. Garnett ruled that manufacturers and distributors of flavored vape brands cannot dismiss the lawsuit filed by New York State, allowing the case to move forward.
Court Finds Misleading Vape Safety Claims Plausible
The judge stated that, although certain claims were dismissed as duplicative, the core allegations of New York State’s lawsuit remain intact.
The ruling confirms that vape companies will continue to face allegations of repeated and continuous violations of state and federal laws, public nuisance, and grossly negligent marketing practices.
Judge Garnett noted that New York State has alleged that defendants falsely promoted their flavored vapes as “generally safe” and not harmful—claims that contradict evidence linking vape use to respiratory, cardiovascular, and cognitive health risks.
Allegations of Illegal Sales and PACT Act Violations
New York Attorney General Letitia James has accused several vape companies of systematically violating state and federal laws.
According to the February 2025 complaint, the defendants include Puff Bar, Demand Vape, Mi-One, and Price Point.
The lawsuit alleges these companies manufactured and distributed flavored disposable vapes that are illegal for retail sale in New York, and that they shipped products directly to consumers in violation of the federal PACT Act.
Marketing Tactics Allegedly Targeted Teenagers
Attorney General James stated that the investigation found these companies made vape products easily accessible near schools and used social media, along with celebrity influencers, to attract young consumers.
The complaint further alleges that the companies were aware of the health risks—especially for teenagers—but continued marketing and selling their products even after New York’s flavored vape ban in 2020 and related actions by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
Additionally, New York State claims that none of the companies obtained FDA authorization for the flavored products and ignored warning letters requiring them to halt sales.





